Changes between Version 7 and Version 8 of Taskforces/CMDI/Meeting20170918


Ignore:
Timestamp:
09/18/17 13:23:00 (7 years ago)
Author:
Twan Goosen
Comment:

Notes

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • Taskforces/CMDI/Meeting20170918

    v7 v8  
    2323
    2424== Agenda ==
     25* Agenda
    2526* CLAVAS vocabularies
    2627 * Status of proposed new vocabularies
     
    3233
    3334== Notes ==
     35
     36=== CLAVAS ===
     37* Production instance @ Meertens on the way. Depends on release of OpenSKOS 2.1 (framework for vocabularies), code of which needs to be merged. [TODO]
     38    * -> vocabularies.clarin.eu (not yet the final version)
     39* ISO639-3 vocabulary is in there, but an old version - aligned with component registry
     40==== Vocabularies in preparation ====
     41
     42===== IANA media types (mime types) vocabulary =====
     43        * Can be retrieved in XML format. This can be converted into a vocabulary (work by Menzo @ Meertens).
     44        * (Nearly) ready to be included in CLAVAS in principle, only descriptions and URIs/handles (internal vs ‘natural’) need to be decided on.
     45        * Add narrower concepts for e.g. TEI (more specific resource types than ‘plain’ media types allows for) by using skos:inScheme and skos:Broader
     46        * On basis of this a component can be created for all media types
     47        * [TODO] Subcollections need some thought/work, API does not know about such subsets
     48===== Licences =====
     49        * Norway has licences spreadsheet; Menzo has converted this to SKOS. Not all information is represented there (yet).
     50            * Concept scheme per licence family (e.g. GNU, CLARIN, CC)
     51            * [TODO] Properties (PUB/ACA/RES + BY, NC, SA etc) to be encoded - probably we will have to define our own vocabulary for this
     52        * Merging/aligning with curation TF’s licence vocabulary
     53            * [TODO] This is the plan but has to be worked out
     54        * Vocabulary ownership (‘content admin’)
     55            * Legally: Oddrun talked to Gunn Inger. Ownership is now university. Should be ok to base a SKOS vocab on it.
     56            * A person or group of persons has to be responsible for the content. Obvious candidates would be curation task force and/or legal issues committee
     57            * [TODO] Discussion with experts (legal issues committee, ..) still pending
     58===== Organisations =====
     59        * Menzo started creating a vocabulary based on ‘old’ organisations vocabulary from first version of CLAVAS that got out of sync and was lacking in (linked) information
     60        * New vocabulary bootstrapped from information in the VLO
     61        * Added information
     62            * Spelling variations, multilingual labels
     63            * Also typos -> hidden labels
     64        * Intended applications
     65            * Organisations component(s) - primarily as an open vocabulary
     66            * Harmonisation of spelling variations
     67        * Collaborative curation effort needed
     68Ideally directly in XML, sharing the file on GitHub
     69        * Look up/sync with authority file (e.g. viaf.org), use URI found there
     70===== Resource types(?) =====
     71        * Curation efforts: Coverage of resource type in VLO is bad. Could be improved by deriving from resource type -> cross facet mapping, will be integrated in VLO.
     72        * [TODO] Contact Jan Odijk about this?
     73        * Workshop to get to such a unified vocabulary? (see other business)
     74        * A lot of information is already there
     75
     76=== CCR ===
     77* Importance stressed in best practices
     78* Not much has happened recently, some contact among coordinators
     79* New pending sets of proposals:
     80    * IDS submitted proposals for 2 concepts
     81    * Jan Odijk is proposing concepts based on CLARIN-NL…
     82    * Concepts mapping directly to VLO facets
     83* (Required) action by coordinators
     84    * Discussion -> approval; Then Menzo can import them
     85    * Menzo, Oddrun: will attempt to get the procedure on track again (Ineke is now involved again)
     86    * “Coordination of coordinators” is lacking
     87        * When would coordinators meet? Raise as issue to ERIC. [TODO]
     88    * CCR coordinators can meet during CAC (over lunch?)
     89        * [TODO] [Report here]
     90
     91=== Helpdesk ===
     92
     93* Nothing happened: no support requests in the past 100 days.
     94* Request before were handled well
     95
     96=== Best practices ===
     97
     98* Draft at https://www.clarin.eu/content/cmdi-best-practice-guide
     99* Will be presented at Bazaar and paper session
     100    * [TODO] Can ask centre committee representative to mention this in plenary “Short reports on Committee meetings, by the respective chairs” slot
     101    * Task force members are requested to be present to talk CMDI (BP) :)
     102* Schematron implementation of some best practices
     103    * By Menzo, incorporated in toolkit (dev branch, see https://github.com/clarin-eric/cmdi-toolkit/tree/develop/src/main/resources/toolkit/sch)
     104        * Can be used to evaluate component files or records, e.g. using oXygen
     105    * Implementation brings additional insight into best practices, could be reflected in next editing iteration (e.g. overlapping BPs)
     106    * [TODO] To be integrated into curation module
     107
     108=== Other business ===
     109
     110* Workshop(s)/hackathon towards proposal for curation workflow and practices (see CLAVAS)
     111    * Start with (for example) resource types - vocabulary + mapping definitions
     112    * Small group of people (4-5) willing to work on this
     113        * Scopes: content and workflow (separate + combined sessions)
     114    * [TODO] be organised/hosted by Vienna
     115        * Within the next quarter/half year