Resource Type

proposed vocabulary

basic principle: to decompose the values and rather allow the use of a combination of values to describe one resource. Example:

AnnotatedTextCorpus = collection text annotation 
Audio-recording with transcription = audio annotation

​Collecting possible definitions from external sources in a gsheet

annotation

audio / audioRecording

collection

structuredData

grammar

image

lexicalResource

physicalObject

text

video / videoRecording

software

set of instructions / code that need to be executed / run. (May need download and installation) As opposed to service that can be used directly

service

a software system available online that provides one or more functions usable by humans and other systems (based on DCMI-type)

(interactiveResource)

could be further divided into:

• standalone application = meant for human interaction, has to be executed on local computer
• web application = meant for human interaction, available online, accessible via web browser
• webservice = api = meant for machine interaction, available online, accessible via defined protocol

"tool" seems to be too ambiguous and it's use should be discourages (could be altLabel for interactiveResource)

Comparison of different vocabularies

propositions from within CLARIN, but also from external sources.

still check: ​http://schema.org/MediaObject

VLO Taskforce	DCMI Type Vocabulary	Odijk Resource Type	Odijk Hierarchy	Menzo		"current final" vocabulary
annotatedText	Text	textAnnotation		annotation	annotation + text
audioRecording	Sound	audio	data	audio		audioRecording
collection	Collection	collection	data	collection		collection
corpus	Collection	collection	data	collection		collection (+ text)
database	Dataset	structered data	data	structured data		structuredData
dataset:experimentalData	Dataset	structured data	data
dataset:fieldworkMaterial	Dataset	structured data	data
dataset:surveyData	Dataset	structured data	data
dataset:testData	Dataset	structured data	data
grammar		lexicalResource ??	data	grammar		grammar
image	(Image, StillImage?)	image	data	image		image
lexicalResource	Text	(lexicalResource, lexicalResource/monolingual, lexicalResource/valency lexicon, Semantic lexicalResource)	data	lexicalResource		lexicalResource
physicalObject	PhysicalObject?	physicalObject	analogue object	physicalObject		physicalObject
plainText	Text	Running Natural Language Text	data	text / running natural language text		text
session	Event	audio	data	??
teachingMaterial	(Text, Sound, MovingImage?)*	(audio, video, Running Language Text)*	data	-		-
tool	Service	service	software	tool	interactive resource	software / service
toolChain	Service	service chain	software	tool	interactive resource	software / service
videoRecording	MovingImage?	(video, audio+video)	data	video		videoRecording
webApplication	Interactive Resource	application	software	tool+service	interactive resource	interactiveResource / service
webService	Service	service	software	service	interactive resource	interactiveService /
unspecified		unspecified	other
other		other	other