Changes between Version 9 and Version 10 of Taskforces/FCS/Advanced DataView Example


Ignore:
Timestamp:
08/03/15 09:08:54 (9 years ago)
Author:
Oliver Schonefeld
Comment:

add another advanced fcs proposal

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified

  • Taskforces/FCS/Advanced DataView Example

    v9 v10  
    269269
    270270
    271 === Proposal N ===
    272 * Who: XYZ (Center XYZ)
    273 * What: (shot description)
     271=== Proposal 4 ===
     272* Who: Oliver (IDS)
     273* What: Stand-off representation of MPI example
    274274* Code:
    275275{{{
    276 <!-- Put you XML code here -->
    277 }}}
    278 * Issues/Discussion:
    279   * ...
    280 
    281 
     276#!xml
     277fcs>
     278    <layers time-unit="millis" audio-file-ref="http://hdl.handle.net/8015/1234567890">
     279        <layer id="http://endpoint.example.org/layers/orth1" type="orth">
     280            <span start="1"  end="1"  time-start="0"    time-end="173">t</span>
     281            <span start="3"  end="4"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">da</span>
     282            <span start="6"  end="7"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">'s</span>
     283            <span start="9"  end="10" time-start="304"  time-end="480">de</span>
     284            <span start="12" end="16" time-start="480"  time-end="1119">enige</span>
     285            <span start="18" end="22" time-start="1339" time-end="1901">echte</span>
     286            <span start="24" end="27" time-start="1901" time-end="2427">hoop</span>
     287            <span start="29" end="32" time-start="3084" time-end="3493">voor</span>
     288            <span start="34" end="36" time-start="3493" time-end="3754">ons</span>
     289            <span start="38" end="43" time-start="3754" time-end="4274">mensen</span>
     290        </layer>
     291        <layer id="http://endpoint.example.org/layers/words1" type="words">
     292            <span start="1"  end="1"  time-start="0"    time-end="173">word</span>
     293            <span start="3"  end="4"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">word</span>
     294            <span start="6"  end="7"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">word</span>
     295            <span start="9"  end="10" time-start="304"  time-end="480">word</span>
     296            <span start="12" end="16" time-start="480"  time-end="1119">word</span>
     297            <span start="18" end="22" time-start="1339" time-end="1901">word</span>
     298            <span start="24" end="27" time-start="1901" time-end="2427">word</span>
     299            <span start="29" end="32" time-start="3084" time-end="3493">word</span>
     300            <span start="34" end="36" time-start="3493" time-end="3754">word</span>
     301            <span start="38" end="43" time-start="3754" time-end="4274">word</span>
     302        </layer>
     303        <layer id="http://endpoint.example.org/layers/pos1" type="pos" alt-value-info="CGN POS tagset">
     304            <span start="1"  end="1"  time-start="0"    time-end="173"  alt-value="SPEC(afgebr)">X</span>
     305            <span start="3"  end="4"  time-start="173"  time-end="304"  alt-value="VNW(aanw,pron,stan,vol,3o,ev)">PRON</span>
     306            <span start="6"  end="7"  time-start="173"  time-end="304"  alt-value="WW(pv,tgw,ev)">VERB</span>
     307            <span start="9"  end="10" time-start="304"  time-end="480"  alt-value="LID(bep,stan,rest)">DET</span>
     308            <span start="12" end="16" time-start="480"  time-end="1119" alt-value="VNW(onbep,det,stan,prenom,met-e,rest)">DET</span>
     309            <span start="18" end="22" time-start="1339" time-end="1901" alt-value="ADJ(prenom,basis,met-e,stan)">ADJ</span>
     310            <span start="24" end="27" time-start="1901" time-end="2427" alt-value="N(soort,ev,basis,zijd,stan)">NOUN</span>
     311            <span start="29" end="32" time-start="3084" time-end="3493" alt-value="VZ(init)">ADP</span>
     312            <span start="34" end="36" time-start="3493" time-end="3754" alt-value="VNW(pr,pron,obl,vol,1,mv)">PRON</span>
     313            <span start="38" end="43" time-start="3754" time-end="4274" alt-value="N(soort,mv,basis)">NOUN</span>
     314        </layer>
     315        <layer id="http://endpoint.example.org/layers/lemma1" type="lemma">
     316            <span start="1"  end="1"  time-start="0"    time-end="173">_</span>
     317            <span start="3"  end="4"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">dat</span>
     318            <span start="6"  end="7"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">zijn</span>
     319            <span start="9"  end="10" time-start="304"  time-end="480">de</span>
     320            <span start="12" end="16" time-start="480"  time-end="1119">enig</span>
     321            <span start="18" end="22" time-start="1339" time-end="1901">echt</span>
     322            <span start="24" end="27" time-start="1901" time-end="2427">hoop</span>
     323            <span start="29" end="32" time-start="3084" time-end="3493">voor</span>
     324            <span start="34" end="36" time-start="3493" time-end="3754">ons</span>
     325            <span start="38" end="43" time-start="3754" time-end="4274">mens</span>
     326        </layer>
     327        <layer id="http://endpoint.example.org/layers/phonetics1" type="phonetics">
     328            <span start="1"  end="1"  time-start="0"    time-end="173">t@</span>
     329            <span start="3"  end="4"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">dAz</span>
     330            <span start="6"  end="7"  time-start="173"  time-end="304">dAz</span>
     331            <span start="9"  end="10" time-start="304"  time-end="480">d@</span>
     332            <span start="12" end="16" time-start="480"  time-end="1119">en@G@</span>
     333            <span start="18" end="22" time-start="1339" time-end="1901">Ext@</span>
     334            <span start="24" end="27" time-start="1901" time-end="2427">hop</span>
     335            <span start="29" end="32" time-start="3084" time-end="3493">for</span>
     336            <span start="34" end="36" time-start="3493" time-end="3754">Ons</span>
     337            <span start="38" end="43" time-start="3754" time-end="4274">mEns@</span>
     338        </layer>
     339    </layers>
     340</fcs>
     341}}}
     342* Discussion:
     343  * No preferred/primary layer, all layers are equal
     344  * Each {{{<layer>}}} has a {{{@type}}}, which denotes the type of the layer (closed controlled vocabulary)
     345    * If more layers of a certain type are available, the Aggregator would initially display the first.
     346  * Each {{{<layer>}}} has an {{{@id}}}, which uniquely identifies the layer (in regard to the xml snippet); URIs are used to foster uniqueness
     347  * Each {{{<span>}}} has {{{@start}}} and {{{@end}}} offset to establish the relations between other spans
     348  * The actual "content" is stored as PCDATA in {{{<span>}}}. Additional data, e.g. the original tags in case of pos, can be supplied in the {{{@alt-value}}} attribute. Information about what is contained there must be present in {{{@alt-value-info}}} on {{{<layer>}}}.
     349  * Optionally a {{{<span>}}} may carry {{{@time-start}}} and {{{@time-end}}} elements; the value type is denoted by {{{@time-unit}}} on {{{<layers>}}}. Additionally a reference to a audio-file can be supplied by {{{@audio-file-ref}}} on {{{<layers>}}}; this can be used to generate links for playback
     350* Issues:
     351  * Quite a lot of redundancy (especially when all segments more or less are the same across layers)
     352  * Time info adds even more redundancy. Furthermore, it's unclear how this information is supposed to be combined for a direct playback link.
     353    * Possible solution: endpoints needs to provide complete and valid playback link?
     354  * "Maker layers" (e.g. "words") only mark intervals but contain useless PCDATA
     355    * Possible solution: allow empty PCDATA (or better empty {{{<span>}}} elements in that case?
     356  * What is the Aggregator supposed to display, if it wants/needs to display offsets? The artificial characters offsets make no real sense in the spoken data example. Nice start end offsets (e.g. 00:01:12.22/00:01:23.42) would probably be nicer.
     357    * Possible solution: add a display label?
    282358
    283359== General Discussion ==