Opened 10 years ago

Closed 9 years ago

#537 closed defect (wontfix)

Replacement of placeholder URLs

Reported by: Olaf Seibert 1 Owned by:
Priority: minor Milestone: DASISH backend
Component: DASISH backend Version:
Keywords: Cc: olhsha

Description

In the example at https://trac.clarin.eu/wiki/DASISH/XSD%20and%20XML#Makinganewannotation for posting a new annotation, there are placeholders for 3 things:

<annotation URI="xxx"

ownerRef="yyy">

and

<targetInfo ref="tmpTarget">

Below that, it is stated that "The temporary URIs/references are replaced with permanent references.".

I wasn't sure if this replacement happens only in those locations I show above, or throughout the body as well, so I tried the following. I use the placeholder URLs for target and annotation inside my body. I already know what my principal is so I don't use placeholders for that. 

POST https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/annotations

 <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<annotation xmlns="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" ownerRef="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/principals/00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000221" URI="__TEMP_ANNOTATION_REF__" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit https://svn.clarin.eu/DASISH/t5.6/schema/trunk/annotator-schema/src/main/resources/DASISH-schema.xsd">
    <headline>new</headline>
    <lastModified>2014-04-24T12:46:44Z</lastModified>
    <body>
        <xmlBody>
            <mimeType>text/xml</mimeType>
            <ColTime xmlns:ns3="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit" xmlns="" ColTimeMessageID="3f5ea2c7-0f8b-49c0-bd43-5d80812aa75d" URL="__TEMP_ANNOTATION_REF__" noNamespaceSchemaLocation="http://www.mpi.nl/tools/elan/comments.xsd">
                <Metadata>
                    <Initials>OS</Initials>
                    <Sender>sender@dom.ain</Sender>
                    <Recipient>recei@pi.ent</Recipient>
                    <CreationDate>2014-04-24T12:46:44Z</CreationDate>
                    <ModificationDate>2014-04-24T12:46:44Z</ModificationDate>
                    <Category>unknown</Category>
                    <Status>unknown</Status>
                </Metadata>
                <MediaFile ColTimeID=""/>
                <AnnotationFile ColTimeID="__TEMP_TARGET_REF__" type="EAF">urn:nl-mpi-tools-elan-eaf:59d08e6a-5cd9-4aed-8aa4-7074c270e636#t=4.500/4.980;tier=Gloss_RH</AnnotationFile>
                <Message>new</Message>
            </ColTime>
        </xmlBody>
    </body>
    <targets>
        <targetInfo ref="__TEMP_TARGET_REF__">
            <link>urn:nl-mpi-tools-elan-eaf:59d08e6a-5cd9-4aed-8aa4-7074c270e636</link>
            <version></version>
        </targetInfo>
    </targets>
    <permissions public="read">
        <permission level="write" principalRef="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/principals/00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000221"/>
    </permissions>
</annotation>

and I got back this:

<responseBody xmlns="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit https://svn.clarin.eu/DASISH/t5.6/schema/trunk/annotator-schema/src/main/resources/DASISH-schema.xsd">
    <annotation URI="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/annotations/dc95154f-4b54-4f81-909b-fee05aea1ee2" ownerRef="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/principals/00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000221">
        <headline>new</headline>
        <lastModified>2014-04-24T12:46:44.692631Z</lastModified>
        <body>
            <xmlBody>
                <mimeType>text/xml</mimeType>
                <ColTime xmlns:ns3="http://www.dasish.eu/ns/addit" xmlns="" ColTimeMessageID="3f5ea2c7-0f8b-49c0-bd43-5d80812aa75d" URL="__TEMP_ANNOTATION_REF__" noNamespaceSchemaLocation="http://www.mpi.nl/tools/elan/comments.xsd">
                    <Metadata>
                        <Initials>OS</Initials>
                        <Sender>sender@dom.ain</Sender>
                        <Recipient>recei@pi.ent</Recipient>
                        <CreationDate>2014-04-24T12:46:44Z</CreationDate>
                        <ModificationDate>2014-04-24T12:46:44Z</ModificationDate>
                        <Category>unknown</Category>
                        <Status>unknown</Status>
                </Metadata>
                    <MediaFile ColTimeID=""/>
                    <AnnotationFile ColTimeID="8f79c5ab-1bf4-484f-a9ad-48ec6d85c846" type="EAF">urn:nl-mpi-tools-elan-eaf:59d08e6a-5cd9-4aed-8aa4-7074c270e636#t=4.500/4.980;tier=Gloss_RH</AnnotationFile>
                    <Message>new</Message>
            </ColTime>
            </xmlBody>
        </body>
        <targets>
            <targetInfo ref="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/targets/8f79c5ab-1bf4-484f-a9ad-48ec6d85c846">
                <link>urn:nl-mpi-tools-elan-eaf:59d08e6a-5cd9-4aed-8aa4-7074c270e636</link>
                <version></version>
            </targetInfo>
        </targets>
        <permissions public="read">
            <permission principalRef="https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/principals/00000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000221" level="write"/>
        </permissions>
    </annotation>
    <actionList>
        <action>
            <object>https://lux16.mpi.nl/ds/webannotator/api/targets/8f79c5ab-1bf4-484f-a9ad-48ec6d85c846</object>
            <message>CREATE_CACHED_REPRESENTATION</message>
        </action>
    </actionList>
</responseBody>

The interesting thing here is that ColTimeID="__TEMP_TARGET_REF__" has been replaced with ColTimeID="8f79c5ab-1bf4-484f-a9ad-48ec6d85c846" instead of with a full URL. The part you get does correspond with the last part of the URL.
Also URL="__TEMP_ANNOTATION_REF__" has been left unchanged.

For me it doesn't matter very much, because so far I have just filled in the correct values in those places when I retrieve the comment from the server, on the theory that at some point in the future it might be PUT back, including those corrected values.

I don't know if it was the intention to search/replace for all 3 of the placeholder URLs, but it would be cleaner for my case.

Change History (2)

comment:1 Changed 10 years ago by DefaultCC Plugin

Cc: olhsha added

comment:2 Changed 9 years ago by Sander Maijers

Resolution: → wontfix
Status: new → closed

The project has ended.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.